Martin and Rowling both explore the world in which women struggle to gain importance, which in turn leads them to use their seen innocence as woman and sexuality to gain what they want. In “A Game of Thrones” Cersei Lannister uses social expectation, in this case, woman is sexual objects, to gain what she wants. Similarly in “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix” Umbridge uses physical exaggeration of girlishness, which makes her seem innocent, to gain what she wants within Hogwarts. Sexuality and innocence are facades for both the woman to eventually achieve their goal of power within the hierarchy. Cersei is a proud woman who won't stop at anything to get what she wants, to protect her children. Umbridge is a powerful woman who will do anything in her power to get what she wants, what's best for her. Professor Umbridge is described as “Somebody's Maiden aunt” with a “Horrible pink alice band that matched the fluffy pink cardigan”. Rowling describes her with classic woman stereotypes right down to the constant use of pink, the original stereotypically colour for a woman. Her clothes are used a physical facade for her true intentions. Who would ever expect an innocent woman dressed in pink to have such cruel intentions. “In “A Game of Thrones” Cersei sleeps with people to not only gain power in Westeros but also to protect the mistakes she made and the people she loves. She made the conscious mistake of having children with her brother, instead of the king. Due to those mistakes, she has to work even harder. That again was a choice she made because she could have chosen to not protect her brother and her children, but she wants to keep the power. If she came out with the truth she wouldn’t be in the upper level of the power of hierarchy. Cersei is described as “blonde hair, brilliant green eyes, fair skin, and a slender, graceful figure”, beautiful as well as cunning. She resents the customs put on her because of her gender but uses her beauty to fight those stab those customs in the back. Cersei often a hypocrite as she disapproved of Robert Baratheon hedonistic lifestyle, she as well uses sex and alcohol to avoid true leadership. Which is ironic because she both uses sex to gain what she thinks is “power” but as well as uses it to avoid her true leadership and power. Her and Umbridge are similar in the way they both want more and more, ignoring what they already have. They're trying to reach the highest cabinet without a stepping stool. They only want the most, whether it's hand of the king or minister of magic, they are ignorant of anything in between and feel weak in other positions. Even though both women are in places of power they use further femininity and copulation to reach the highest point in power, evidently failing and falling behind.
Both characters, Cersei and Umbridge and books, A game of thrones and Harry potter and the order of the phoenix, have their similarities as well as their differences. The world of Westeros and Hogwarts are very different places with different societies. The books being set at different times to have different expectations for women and what their job is in the world “A game of thrones” is set in a magical era in which women are seen as unimportant and sexual objects. “I swear, women lose all modesty in the heat.” Every chance for fewer clothes or modesty, even due to something such as heat, is seen as an opportunity for men or done for men. Men are supposed to be strong and fierce “while women sew dragon banners” Sewing, cooking, and being there to sleep with are all woman are seen good for. When women do anything other than that, they are ridiculed and banished by society. Men are also superior even if a woman is better, they get priority. Nothing in the wizarding world has ever seen to be primarily male eccentric. Woman and men educators are of equal balance at Hogwarts, and at Harry's Trial “Dolores Jane Umbridge, Senior Undersecretary to the Minister” And Amelia Bones proceed over the trial. But just like in today's world women never have the opportunity to be in the highest positions of power, always one step down. Having a society, such as Westeros, which limits what woman can do puts barriers in front of the steps woman such as Cersei have to take to gain the highest form of power. Which is also why Cersei never achieves to gain power, she is always seen as lesser whereas Umbridge ends up gaining power within the ministry of magic. Which is why Cersei has to take more extreme measures like using her sexuality, unlike Umbridge who can get away with just using her girlishness innocence. Umbridge as well is dedicated to the values of the ministry of magic and is loyal whereas Cersei hates king's landing and everything it stands for, which is ironic because she is in a way the embodiment of king's landing corrupt and rich, but she pretended to like it in order to keep her children safe. Cersei cares about her children more than anything else, which in a way legitimizes her reasons for her actions. Whereas Umbridge has no one mentioned that she cares about. Someone may say that how can caring about someone being legitimate reasons for being crazy and controlling people. But even though Cersei may be controlling and insane, caring about children makes you do crazy things. People say you love your children more than anything else in the world, they are born from you and are a part of you and us as a society do everything possible to keep them safe. So why if that wrong when done to the extreme, she lives in a society of extremes. Umbridge controls her position of the power from the front lines like a general whereas Cersei controls the power from backstage. Even though both women are controlling and evil they are not the same, they have different opportunities and are placed in different places of power.
Rowling and Martin both use places and objects metonymically to show symbols of hierarchy and power. In Harry potter and the Order of the Phoenix, it's the first time we have a glimpse of the Ministry of Magic and what they are capable of. As well as in ‘A Game of Thrones” we learn about the Iron thrones and it's capabilities. Martin uses the Iron Throne to symbolise power within Westeros, and how it destroys people's relationships. In the beginning, the Iron Throne is talked about as a superior object. What everyone in Westeros aims to be near or be on. “At times, he even sat upon the Iron Throne to dispense king’s justice” Martin uses language such as “At times” which makes it sound like an honour to be seated on this object of elite authority. It is seen as the ideal source of power. “Let them make their case before the Iron Throne” like the person on the Iron throne is irrelevant put the throne itself is the source of judiciary and establishment. "Rebellion against the Iron Throne" Not against the king or the Monarch but against the Iron Throne, an object. We see this similarly used by Rowling when she talks about the Ministry of Magic. “How much power did Dumbledore have to override the Ministry of Magic?” Rowling uses the words “override the ministry of Magic” not a specific person but the source of the power. She consciously doesn't say the Minister of Magic but the ministry of magic as it gives us the idea that the ministry has a whole has the power, not just the individual human being. In other scenarios as well, the Ministry of Magic like it was written as a person has done things. “the Ministry of Magic has revised its decision to destroy your wand forthwith.” Unlike in “A game of Thrones” where the Iron Throne is metonymically used to symbolise the person on the Iron Throne and the power they had to dispense, the Ministry of Magic is metonymically not only as a singular person's form of power and what they can do as an individual but what the system can do in terms of power. Within these contexts the symbols help us understand who and what is the highest on the food chain within these societies. And when comparing the two helps us understand the differences in society. While the Iron Throne is used as a singular object, which in turn shows us that the power is held by one person, the Ministry of Magic is used as a whole, which shows us that it's a system as a whole, not an individual. A system of bureaucracy versus a system of Monarch. Even though Bureaucracy and Monarchy are very different systems of government they both don't put any power in the hands the people. Since Westeros in a monarchy, it makes it even more difficult for Cersei to gain power as there is only a singular source, whereas in the system of bureaucracy everyone has a chance to have control.
You may be wondering how on earth does this matter in the 21st century we live in now. What do power-crazed women who use innocence to gain power have anything to do with our society today. Even though it may not be obvious because we are not in that hierarchy, but the top 0.01% of our society compete for the reigns of power every day. Woman politicians such as Elizabeth Warren and Hillary Clinton sign documents, do interviews and voice their opinion every day in order to gain control of the power from the predominantly male population. Without power in our world, what would we do? Where would we be? No matter how much we don't want to believe it without those power struggles in our world, our society would get nowhere. The reigns of power are always moving from one hand to another in the world. It's constantly changing, moving and flowing like a river. You may be thinking, why do I matter, I’m not in that top 0.01%, What different does it make in my life. The people who have the reigns of power affect the way in which you live your life. They control the actions you take and the things you are allowed to say. You can support your community by being involved and integrated into your local population. Voting and supporting the leaders you think will improve your society and the way in which you live your life. Unlike “Harry Potter” and “A Game of Thrones” we have the opportunity to live in a system of democracy where we matter. Elizabeth Warren, Hillary Clinton, Dolores Umbridge, and Cersei Lannister and strong and powerful women, you often have to take extreme measures and risks in order to protect those they love and gain rank in the system of hierarchy. Women matter in this world, they make up half the population of the world. Support women leaders who want to change the system of male dominant hierarchy and voice their ideas and opinions to the world.
No comments:
Post a Comment